Journal of Greater Khorasan

Journal of Greater Khorasan

Historical Analysis of Achievements and Failures of Hamed Karzai Government (2001-2014)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
mozaffar mazhar 1
moortaza dehqannejad 2
Abolhassan Fayyaz 3
1 PhD Candidate in Islamic Iranian History, Department of History, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
2 b) Professor, Department of History, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran.
3 c) Associate Professor, Department of History, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
10.22034/jgk.2023.410066.1142
Abstract
The present study aims to explain the factors contributing to the achievements and failures of Hamid Karzai's government. According to historical evidence, the Karzai administration was relatively successful in delivering basic services such as security, justice, and welfare. However, despite the support of the international community and assistance from the United States, it failed to establish a system of governance acceptable to the citizens of Afghanistan and the donor countries. Therefore, addressing this issue is crucial for understanding the conditions of governance in Afghanistan. Accordingly, the main research question is: What factors contributed to the achievements and failures of the Karzai government? This study employs a descriptive-analytical method and is based on a systematic review of all available documents and sources. The findings indicate that, during its thirteen-year rule and with the support of the international community, the Karzai government achieved relative progress in the areas of military development, education, human rights, democracy, freedom of expression, women's rights, and infrastructure reconstruction and modernization. However, the lack of a clear policy, weak national unity discourse, interference of regional countries, mismanagement of foreign aid, and the failure to combat administrative corruption were among the main obstacles and reasons for the government’s shortcomings. The overall conclusion of this study suggests that governance in Afghanistan is influenced by a complex set of internal and external factors, and success in this area requires a comprehensive approach that considers all variables and conditions, both domestic and international.
Keywords
Modernization
Inefficiency
State
Hamid Karzai
Afghanistan

Subjects

  • Abdolghafor, A. (2003). How Afghanistan's National Identity Is. Tehran: Irfan Publications. (In Persian (
  • Abizh, W. (2005). Afghanistan, the Model of American Democracy, from the Imposition of Terrorism to the Export of Democracy. Kabul: Afghanistan Darul-Nasher Publishing House. (In Persian. (
  • Amiri, J. (2010). The Fate of Democracy in Afghanistan. Kabul: Saeed Publications. (In Persian).
  • Andishmand, M. A. (2016). Nation-State Building in Afghanistan. Kabul: Saeed Publications. (In Persian).
  • Ansari, Kh. B. A. (2002). Afghanistan in Oil Fire (3rd Ed.). Peshawar: Maiwand Publications. (In Persian).
  • Ayubi, S. A. (2009). Who is a Journalist? What is Journalism? Kabul: Maiwand Publications. (In Persian).
  • Bakhtiari, M. Q. (2005). The Roots of the Crisis and the Way of Political Development in Afghanistan. Kabul: Noor Publications Research Institute. (In Persian).
  • Bahoosh, M. and Zanganeh, P. (2017). Explaining the Crisis Process between the United States and Afghanistan after the Cold War. Iranian Research Letter of International Politics, 6(1), 27–52. https://irlip.um.ac.ir/article_29085.html
  • Douglas, S., & Madhi, A. (2011). Local Governance in Afghanistan, From the Bottom Up. Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit. (In English & Persian).
  • Emami, H. E. (2007). Afghanistan and the Rise of the Taliban. Tehran: Shab Publications. (In Persian).
  • Ershad, Z. H. (2011). America's Strategy in Afghanistan after the Taliban. Tak Publications. (In Persian).
  • Fanous, A. A. (2019). Media Freedom in Opinion and Practice. Kabul: Azam Publications. (In Persian).
  • Firozi, S. M., Yousufi, F., Afzali, N. A., & Basharat Rahamani, M. B. (2023). Socio-cultural Contexts of Order and Security in Afghanistan. The Fundamental and Applied Studies of the Islamic World, 5(1), 105–128. https://journal.iiwfs.com/article_172903_en.html. (In Persian with English abstract).
  • Firozi, S. M., Zare Shahabadi, A., & Emamalizadeh, H. (2022). Analyzing the Contexts and Foundations of the Erosion of Social Hope in Afghanistan. Journal of Political Sociology of Islamic World, 10(21), 349–374. https://iws.shahed.ac.ir/article_4212.html (in Persian with English abstract).
  • Hassanzadeh, Z. (2010). Studying the Influence of the Taliban on the State-Nation-Building in Afghanistan. Tehran: Afsun Publications. (In Persian)
  • Hashemi, S. H. (2022). A Historical Approach to Identifying the Factors of Crisis and Political Disorder in Contemporary Afghanistan. Ma'rifat Farhangi Ejtemai (Cultural and Social Knowledge), 13(1), 53. (In Persian).
  • Harvi, A. (2017). Nation building process in Afghanistan. Saudi Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, 2(5), 38–45.
  • Jennifer, M. (2016). Local Governance in Afghanistan. United States Institute of Peace.
  • Karwal, M. I. (2004). Bitter and Inspiring Lessons of Afghanistan (3rd ed.). Kabul: Maiwand Publications. (In Persian).
  • Khatibi, A. I. (2019). Media and Globalization of Culture. Kabul: Saeed Publications. (In Persian).
  • Mahboubi, G. A. (2013). Foreign military presence in Afghanistan and the spread of extremism in Pakistan. Kabul: Center for Strategic and Regional Studies.. (In Persian).
  • Mobarez, A. H. (2011). Analysis of Afghanistan's Foreign Policy from Ahmad Shah Babai Durrani to Hamid Karzai (1st Ed.). Kabul: Saeed Publications. (In Persian).
  • Normohammadi, M. (2019). State–society relations and fragile foundations of government in Afghanistan.
  • Rahimi, M. S. (2011). Afghanistan Geopolitics. Kabul: Maiwand Publications. (In Persian).
  • Rasoul, S. (2004). A Look at the Reign of Amani (3rd Ed.). Kabul: Maiwand Publications. (In Persian).
  • Rezaei, N., & Ali, A. (2013). Autopsy of Afghanistan Crisis. Kabul: Today's Afghanistan Publishing Center - Meiotic Institute. (In Persian).
  • Sajjadi, S. A. Q. (2001). Sociology of Afghanistan. Qom: Qom Book Publishing House. (In Persian).
  • Sardarnia, K., & Hooseini, S. M. (2014). Social Challenges of Modern State-Building in Afghanistan. World Politics, 3(3), 37–63. (In Persian).
  • Shahrani, N. (2009). Afghanistan's Alternatives for Peace, Governance and Development: Turning Nationals into Citizens and Rulers into Servants of the People. Today's Politics Magazine, 5(23). (In Persian).
  • Shafiei, N. (2008). Reproducing Power in Afghanistan: Explaining the Taliban's Rise to Power. Central Eurasian Studies Quarterly, 2(4). https://jcep.ut.ac.ir/article_20465.html. (In Persian with English abstract)
  • Sharifi, M. (2016). America's Role in the Middle East Crises. Tehran: Farhang. (In Persian).
  • Shafiee, N. (2023). Strategic Issues and Trends in Afghanistan. Middle East Studies, 29(4), 98–110. (In Persian).
  • Spanta, R. D. (2016). Afghanistan’s politics: A narrative from within. Kabul: Afghan Institute for Strategic Studies.
  • Yavari, A. A. (2018). Management in the Ownership of the Press in Afghanistan. Media Magazine, 18(2). (In Persian(
  • Zare Shahabadi, A., & Firozi, S. M. (2022). The Effective Social Factors of Tendency to Drugs among the Youth of Kabul City. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad Journal of Social Sciences, 19(1), 134–109. https://social.um.ac.ir/article_42560.html (In Persian with English abstract).

  • Receive Date 04 August 2023
  • Revise Date 23 October 2023
  • Accept Date 11 April 2024